Joint Statistical Meetings

How many success-or-failure observations should we collect from a computer simulation? Often, researchers use space-filling design of experiments when planning modeling and simulation (M&S) studies. We are not satisfied with existing guidance on justifying the number of runs when developing these designs, either because the guidance is insufficiently justified, does not provide an unambiguous answer, or is not based on optimizing a statistical measure of merit. Analysts should use confidence interval margin of error as the statistical measure of merit for M&S studies intended to characterize overall M&S behavioral trends....

Many DOD systems undergo operational testing, which is a field test involving realistic combat conditions. Data, analysis, and reporting are the fundamental outcomes of operational test, which support leadership decisions. The importance of data standardization and interoperability is widely recognized by leadership in DoD, however, there are no generally recognized standards for the management and handling of data (format, pedigree, architecture, transferability, etc.) in the DOD. In this presentation, I will review a set of data principles that we believe DOD should adopt to improve how it manages test data....

Modeling and simulation (M&S) can be a useful tool when testers and evaluators need to augment the data collected during a test event. When planning M&S, testers use experimental design techniques to determine how much and which types of data to collect, and they can use space-filling designs to spread out test points across the operational space. Fast flexible space-filling designs (FFSFDs) are a type of space-filling design useful for M&S because they work well in design spaces with disallowed combinations and permit the inclusion of categorical factors....

To improve test planning for evaluating system reliability, we propose the use of Bayesian methods to incorporate supplementary data and reduce testing duration. Furthermore, we recommend Bayesian methods be employed in the analysis phase to better quantify uncertainty. We find that when using Bayesian Methods for test planning we can scope smaller tests and using Bayesian methods in analysis results in a more precise estimate of reliability – improving uncertainty quantification....

Fragmentation analysis is a critical piece of the live fire test and evaluation (LFT&E) of the lethality and vulnerability aspects of warheads. But the traditional methods for data collection are expensive and laborious. New optical tracking technology is promising to increase the fidelity of fragmentation data, and decrease the time and costs associated with data collection. However, the new data will be complex, three-dimensional “fragmentation clouds,” possibly with a time component as well, and there will be a larger number of individual data points....

Accurately presenting model estimates with appropriate uncertainties is critical to the credibility and defensibility of anypiece of statistical analysis. When dealing with complex data that require hierarchical covariance structures, many of the standardapproaches for visualizing uncertainty are insufficient. One such case is data fit with log-linear autoregressive mixed effectsmodels. Data requiring such an approach have three exceptional characteristics.1. The data are sampled in “groups” that exhibit variation unexplained by other model factors....

The goal of operation testing (OT) is to evaluate the effectiveness and suitability of military systems for use by trained military users in operationally realistic environments. Operators perform missions and make systems function. Thus, adequate OT must assess not only system performance and technical capability across the operational space, but also the quality of human-system interactions. Software systems in particular pose a unique challenge to testers. While some software systems may inherently be deterministic in nature, once placed in their intended environment with error-prone humans and highly stochastic networks, variability in outcomes often occurs, so tests often need to account for both “bug” finding and characterizing variability....

Recently, the principles of Design of Experiments (DOE) have been implemented as amethod of increasing the statistical rigor of operational tests. The focus has been on ensuringcoverage of the operational envelope in terms of system effectiveness. DOE is applicable inreliability analysis as well. A reliability standard, ANSI-0009, advocates the use Design forReliability (DfR) early in the product development cycle in order to design-in reliability. Robustparameter design (RPD) first used by Taguchi and then by the response surface communityprovides insights on how DOE can be used to make a products and processes invariant tochanges in factors....